Not every subcontractor needs to provide a performance and payment bond. In fact, many experienced general contractors take a strategic approach, requiring bonds only when the additional protection justifies the cost and administrative effort.

So how do you decide? The answer depends on the project, the subcontractor, and your overall risk tolerance.

In this guide, we’ll cover the most common situations where subcontractor performance and payment bonds make sense—and when they may not be necessary.

Quick Answer

Many general contractors require subcontractor performance and payment bonds when:

  • Working with a new or unfamiliar subcontractor
  • Awarding a high-value subcontract
  • Managing complex or mission-critical scopes of work
  • Building on public projects
  • Working on projects with tight schedules
  • Meeting owner, lender, or contract requirements

Rather than bonding every subcontractor, many contractors focus on the situations where the financial protection provides the greatest value.

Why require subcontractor performance bonds?

A subcontractor performance bond helps protect the general contractor if a bonded subcontractor fails to fulfill their contractual obligations.

A payment bond helps protect eligible suppliers and lower-tier subcontractors if the bonded subcontractor fails to pay for labor or materials.

Together, these bonds can help reduce financial risk, improve subcontractor screening, and provide additional confidence before work begins.

When should general contractors require subcontractor performance bonds?

1. You’re Hiring a New Subcontractor

Every new subcontractor represents some level of uncertainty. Even if they come highly recommended, you may have limited firsthand knowledge of their:

  • Financial strength
  • Project history
  • Staffing capacity
  • Experience with similar work

Requiring performance and payment bonds adds another layer of evaluation because the surety independently reviews the subcontractor before issuing the bonds.

💡 ZipBonds Insight

Bonding isn’t about assuming a subcontractor will fail. It’s about understanding and managing risk before a project begins—especially when you’re working with a company for the first time.

2. The Subcontract Represents a Significant Dollar Value

As subcontract values increase, so does the potential financial impact of a default.

Replacing a subcontractor mid-project often involves much more than hiring someone new. You may also face:

  • Schedule delays
  • Higher completion costs
  • Coordination challenges
  • Owner concerns
  • Additional administrative time

For larger subcontract values, many contractors view bonding as an important risk management tool.

3. The Scope Is Critical to the Project

Some scopes have a greater impact on the overall schedule than others.

Examples may include:

  • Structural steel
  • Mechanical, electrical, and plumbing (MEP)
  • Concrete
  • Sitework
  • Specialty systems

If delays in one trade could affect multiple other trades, requiring bonds may provide added peace of mind.

4. The Project Has a Tight Schedule

On fast-track projects, there is often little room for error. If a key subcontractor defaults, replacing them can delay subsequent trades and increase project costs.

Many contractors require bonds for critical scopes on schedule-sensitive projects because the potential consequences of a default are significantly higher.

5. The Owner or Contract Requires It

Some project owners, developers, lenders, or prime contracts require subcontractor performance and payment bonds. In these situations, the decision has already been made for you.

Review your contract documents carefully to understand:

  • Which subcontractors must provide bonds
  • Required bond amounts
  • Submission deadlines
  • Any project-specific bonding requirements

6. You’re Working on a Public Construction Project

Many public construction projects require performance and payment bonds at the prime contractor level. Depending on the owner, project, or contract terms, subcontractor bonding may also be required for certain scopes of work.

Even when it isn’t mandatory, many general contractors choose to require bonds on larger public projects because of the increased contractual obligations and public accountability.

7. The Subcontractor Has Limited Capacity or Experience

A subcontractor may have an excellent reputation but still be taking on a project that’s larger or more complex than anything they’ve completed before. Performance and payment bonds provide another level of financial review in these situations.

The surety evaluates factors such as:

  • Financial strength
  • Work history
  • Organizational capacity
  • Experience with similar projects

This independent underwriting can help identify potential concerns before construction begins.

💡 ZipBonds Insight

One of the biggest benefits of subcontractor bonding happens before the project even starts. The surety’s underwriting process provides an additional review of the subcontractor’s qualifications, helping contractors make more informed decisions.

When Bonding May Not Be Necessary

Not every subcontract requires bonding.

Many contractors choose not to require bonds when:

  • The subcontract value is relatively small.
  • They have a long, successful history with the subcontractor.
  • The scope of work presents limited project risk.
  • The potential impact of a default would be minimal.

Ultimately, the goal is to match your bonding requirements to the level of risk—not to create unnecessary barriers for every subcontractor.

Questions to Ask Before Requiring Subcontractor Bonds

Before awarding a subcontract, consider:

  • Is this a new subcontractor?
  • How critical is this scope of work?
  • What would happen if the subcontractor defaulted?
  • Would replacing this subcontractor significantly delay the project?
  • Are suppliers or lower-tier subcontractors exposed?
  • Does the owner or contract require bonding?

If you answer “yes” to several of these questions, subcontractor bonding may be worth considering.

Decision Matrix: Should this subcontractor be bonded?

Project SituationBonding Recommendation
New subcontractorStrongly consider bonding
Large subcontract valueStrongly consider bonding
Critical project scopeStrongly consider bonding
Public construction projectOften recommended or required
Tight project scheduleFrequently recommended
Long-term, trusted subcontractor on a small projectMay not be necessary

How ZipBonds Helps Contractors Make Smarter Bonding Decisions

Every contractor’s projects—and risk tolerance—are different. That’s why ZipBonds works with contractors to develop practical subcontractor bonding strategies based on their specific needs.

Whether you’re deciding when to require bonds, building a subcontractor bond program, or helping a subcontractor obtain performance and payment bonds, our team can guide you through the process.

Just email support@zipbonds.com, message us on Live Chat, or call 888-435-4191 to speak with an agent. We also have a pre-qualification option for contractors that takes less than three minutes to complete.

Apply online today!

Related Resources

Continue with these related resources: